When people talk about finding the “right person,” they often focus on how the relationship feels. Do I love this person? Am I attracted to them? Do we enjoy being together? Do I miss them when they are gone? Those are all reasonable questions. You probably should enjoy the person you are considering marrying, and attraction is an important part of a romantic relationship. But marriage asks more of two people than dating does, which means choosing someone to marry requires looking beyond how the relationship feels when things are going well.
A better question is whether this is someone with whom you can realistically build a life.
That changes what you pay attention to. Dating gives you an opportunity to learn who another person is; choosing a mate means deciding what that information actually means. You are no longer simply asking whether you like being together. You are beginning to consider whether the two of you can combine your lives, values, responsibilities, families, hopes and weaknesses in a way that has a reasonable chance of working.
A Good Person Is Not Always the Right Person
One of the harder things to accept in dating is that someone can be a genuinely good person and still not be a good person for you to marry. There does not always have to be a villain, a betrayal or some dramatic red flag for a relationship to be wrong for marriage.
Two people can care deeply about each other and still want fundamentally different lives. One may want children while the other does not. One may consider faith central to life while the other sees religion as largely irrelevant. One may want to remain close to family while the other imagines a life that involves frequent relocation, travel or a very different lifestyle.
None of these differences necessarily makes either person wrong. The problem is that marriage eventually turns abstract differences into practical decisions. “We’ll figure that out later” can work for a while when two people are dating, but later eventually arrives.
The purpose of dating is not simply to see whether you can avoid conflict. It is also to discover whether your lives are moving in directions that can reasonably be joined.
Character Matters More Than Charm
Early in a relationship, we usually see people under favorable circumstances. Dates are planned, both people are making an effort, conversations are interesting and everyone tends to put forward a better version of themselves. That is normal. You are not being deceptive simply because you dress better for a date than you do when taking out the trash.
Over time, however, character begins to show itself. You see how someone behaves when they are tired, disappointed, embarrassed, frustrated or inconvenienced. You begin to notice whether they can admit when they are wrong, whether they keep their word, how they treat people who cannot do anything for them and whether responsibility comes naturally or has to be pushed onto someone else.
This does not mean analyzing every behavior or turning ordinary imperfections into “red flags.” People have bad days. They become defensive. They say things they regret. A mature evaluation of another person looks for patterns rather than isolated moments.
That matters because marriage eventually exposes far more of our character than our charm. You will live with the person who exists after the date is over.
Pay Attention to How You Handle Conflict
Many couples worry that disagreement means something is wrong with the relationship. It does not. Two different people are going to disagree, and if a couple dates for a long time without ever disagreeing about anything important, there is at least some possibility that one or both people are avoiding difficult subjects.
What matters much more is how the two of you handle disagreement.
Can you listen when you do not agree? Can either person admit fault without treating an apology as humiliation? Does disagreement quickly become contempt, threats, withdrawal or manipulation, or can the two of you eventually return to the problem and work through it?
Marriage will provide plenty of opportunities for disagreement. Money, sex, children, work, extended family, household responsibilities and simple differences in personality will eventually create tension. The question is not whether conflict will occur but whether you can remain on the same side while dealing with it.
A good potential spouse does not have to agree with you about everything. In fact, that would be unrealistic. What matters is whether disagreement can occur without repeatedly damaging the relationship.
Responsibility Is More Important Than People Sometimes Realize
Marriage is romantic, but it is also remarkably practical. Bills need to be paid, people have to go to work, homes need to be maintained, children may need to be raised, parents grow older and unexpected problems eventually appear.
For that reason, one quality that is easy to underestimate while dating is basic responsibility. Does this person generally do what they say they are going to do? Can they manage ordinary adult obligations? When life becomes difficult, do they begin looking for solutions or immediately look for someone else to rescue them?
This has nothing to do with requiring a perfect career, a large income or flawless finances. People lose jobs, make mistakes and go through difficult seasons. There is a meaningful difference, however, between someone who is struggling and someone who consistently refuses to take responsibility for their own life.
Marriage works much better when both people are capable of carrying some weight.
Talk About the Things That Actually Matter
Couples can spend an extraordinary amount of time together while still avoiding the subjects most likely to affect a future marriage. Money, children, religion, sex, family expectations, career goals and lifestyle are often discussed only vaguely because people are afraid that clarity might expose a difference.
But avoiding a disagreement does not eliminate it. It simply postpones your awareness of it.
If you are seriously considering marriage, you should know whether the other person wants children and have some sense of how the two of you think about raising them. You should understand each other’s attitudes toward money and debt. If faith is important to either person, you should have discussed what role it would play in the marriage and in the lives of future children.
You do not need identical opinions about everything, but you should know what the important differences are before you are married rather than discovering them afterward.
Respect Matters Alongside Love
People talk a great deal about love when choosing a spouse, but respect deserves nearly as much attention. You can feel intense attraction toward someone whose judgment you do not trust. You can even love someone while gradually losing respect for the way they live.
That becomes difficult over time.
When you imagine marrying someone, ask whether there are qualities in that person you genuinely admire. Perhaps it is their integrity, generosity, work ethic, patience, faith, courage or the way they treat their family. Real respect does not require idealizing someone; in fact, it usually becomes more meaningful after you have seen a person’s weaknesses and still recognize qualities you value.
Marriage places two people close enough together that idealized versions eventually disappear. You marry the actual person, not the version you imagined during the first few months of dating.
Do Not Marry Potential
People can change, and good marriages often involve tremendous growth from both spouses. The danger comes when someone makes a decision to marry based primarily on who they believe the other person will eventually become.
If there is something about the relationship that you believe you could not tolerate for the next twenty years, it is risky to assume marriage will fix it. Marriage does not reliably cure addiction, dishonesty, chronic irresponsibility, uncontrolled anger or infidelity. In many cases it simply makes existing problems harder to ignore.
There is nothing wrong with hoping another person grows. We should all continue growing. But the person you are choosing to marry should be someone you can accept as they exist now, not merely someone you believe has the potential to become acceptable later.
There Is No Perfect Choice
Some people become so afraid of choosing the wrong person that they begin searching for a level of certainty that relationships cannot provide. There is no test that can guarantee a successful marriage, and there is no point at which you will know everything about another person.
Choosing a spouse will always involve some uncertainty because human beings themselves are uncertain. People grow, circumstances change and life brings things neither person could have anticipated.
The goal is not perfect certainty. It is enough knowledge, enough shared direction and enough evidence of character and maturity to make a thoughtful commitment.
You are not asking whether this person is perfect. You are asking whether this is a person you know well enough, respect enough and share enough with that the two of you can reasonably choose to build a life together.
That is a much more useful standard.
Before You Decide
If a relationship is becoming serious, it can help to step back from the intensity of the relationship and ask yourself whether you actually know the person you are considering marrying. Do you respect their character? Can you handle disagreement without damaging one another? Do you want roughly the same kind of life? Are you accepting the person who exists now, or are you counting on significant changes later?
You do not need perfect answers to every question, and you do not need to approach marriage as though you are performing a risk assessment. But marriage is important enough to look carefully at what you are choosing.
Dating gives you the opportunity to discover who another person is. Choosing a mate means deciding whether the person you have discovered is someone with whom you are willing to build a life.
That is the transition from dating to discernment.
Not Sure What You’re Seeing Clearly?
When you are emotionally involved in a relationship, it can be difficult to separate attraction, fear, hope and compatibility. Relationship coaching or premarital counseling can provide a place to slow things down, ask better questions and look more clearly at where the relationship is going.
Learn more about Relationship Coaching & Premarital Counseling →